Tuesday, August 19, 2008

Aug. 19 -- A MESSAGE FROM J-ROLL (UPDATED)

BY SCOTT LAUBER

Jimmy Rollins has taped a message to the fans that will be played during tonight's television broadcast. When I see it, I'll let you know what he said. Also, when we see what the fans' reaction is to him, I'll let you know.


Otherwise, J-Roll met with the media after batting practice and didn't back down from his comments last week on the Fox's "Best Damn Sports Show Period." He said he was speaking for several of his teammates, from Ryan Howard to Pat Burrell to Carlos Ruiz. He also said he isn't overly concerned about the reaction tonight because, "at the end of the day, if we win, they'll all be cheering."

Couldn't agree more.

More from J-Roll in a bit, so please check back.

(Update, 7:18 p.m.): Rollins' message was played only for the television audience, not here in the ballpark. But the reaction each time he was announced was mixed between boos and cheers. Here's some more of what he told the media before the game.

"You never know. Some are gonna boo, some are gonna cheer. But I don't care about it. That's the way it is, that's the way it was.

"I guess it's good thing -- it got people talking. It's just one of those things. We're people and athletes and when you make a response about how they feel about certain things it's like 'How dare you.' But the thing is, we're human beings and we all have the right to say things and they have the right to say something, too, and they have.

"The question was asked and that's what it was. It's not like I have an agenda or had an agenda. It was what it was and now I guess it is what it is. People here can take it like they want to take it, but it wasn't a false statement. But it's not like I was trying to take a cheap shot at somebody, either. It wasn't intended that way.

"I was speaking for a lot of guys, I wasn't just speaking for Ryan [Howard]. Ryan's had his share [of boos], I've had my share, Pat [Burrell's] had his share. I think Chase [Utley] hasn't been touched yet and hopefully it remains that way and he keeps coming out here and putting up numbers and they don't need do. But there are definitely guys who come back to the clubhouse or you see them from the dugout going to the plate and you see the expression on their face. It's like 'Man, I've got to try to do something, I've got to figure something out.' And they're halfway defeated before they get up there. But basically it's something nobody pays attention to, it's like 'Go get out of here, you can't play in this city.'

"This isn't even nothing to worry about. It's not like I'm getting beat up on. But people are going to like you for one reason and they're going to dislike you for another reason. And if you just want to play the politically correct game you can do that and get away with how you really feel behind closed doors. Sometimes you speak up and make a stance, it doesn't mean you did anything wrong, you just made a point.

"For every action there's a reaction. Some people are gonna cheer, some people are gonna boo. But at the end of the day, we win and they're all be cheering. And that's what we want. We want to win, they want us to win and they'll all be cheering. But in-game action, we're winning 5-3 and a guy makes an out, that's not something to boo. We're still winning. Let's go out there and score some more runs."


As I wrote in Sunday's paper, this whole thing is a nonsense issue. There are far more important matters involving the Phillies, like, I don't know, winning games. Personally, I think the reason people like Rollins is that he isn't afraid to speak his mind. Last year, he thought the Phillies were the "team to beat" in the NL East. He said it. People loved it. Last week, he expressed how he feels sometimes about Phillies fans. Don't like it? Too bad.

6 comments:

Jamie said...

why should we cheer someone who is hitting worse than cole hamels? at that point you don't even belong on the team(taguchi/bruntlett). i'm not a guy who boo's, but if i did i would boo both of those guys till they ended up leaving town on their own.

Anonymous said...

"Don't like it? Too bad." ?? Really Scott? When did this become the fans versus Rollins AND the writers?
Look, I'm not even disagreeing with what Rollins said, but sometimes the message gets lost in the way it is presented and the timing of the presentation. If he truly wanted to start a discussion that would lead to a positive change then maybe the timing would have been better in the offseason while he was MVP and on top of the world. Maybe it is bad timing to do it when the team and Rollings are underperforming. Perhaps when a guy gets benched for multiple infractions he shouldn't blast the manager and fans in public. Is it possible that the middle of the season wasn't the right time for this discussion?
And I don't buy this "Well I was asked a question, so I answered it" response either. Are we to believe that he will answer any question with complete honesty?

Anonymous said...

Oh, one more thing, is it possible that "The Best Damn Sports Show" wasn't the correct forum for him to enlighten us with his philosophies of fandom? Maybe John Salley wasn't the guy to moderate the debate? See JRoll, I can ask a lot of questions too.

Scott Lauber said...

Anon: I didn't mean to sound like I was taking sides between Rollins and the fans. Quite simply, I was trying to say that you have the right to boo, but that doesn't mean Rollins has to like it. That's all. And if you want to reserve the right to boo (which you should), a player can reserve the right to complain about it.

Also, you're absolutely right that Rollins was the wrong player to make these comments, particularly after being benched twice. The comments also were ill-timed, and I couldn't agree more that "Best Damn Sports Show Period" was the wrong forum.

Anonymous said...

what an awesome job Comcast did with the telecast last night....NOT.....they played that J-Roll tape RIGHT AS HE WAS BIENG ANNOUNCED AT BAT FOR THE FIRST TIME. you didnt even hear the fan reaction.........Comcast, you are a joke

Anonymous said...

Last week, he expressed how he feels sometimes about Phillies fans. Don't like it? Too bad."

yes, Scott, this is exactly what the fans are saying to J-roll right about now......in Philly you have to take the good with the bad...the ticket is, if he plays good (or at least better than he is now) he doesnt ever have to worry about the boo's now does he?